达尔文的怀疑
Darwin's Doubt
Stephen C. Meyer · 初版 2013 年
2人推荐
3位读者提及
8次提及
查尔斯·达尔文深知，生命史上发生过一起重大事件，是他的理论所无法解释的。在如今被称为“寒武纪大爆发”的时期，即5.3亿年前，化石记录中突然涌现出大量动物，而在更古老的岩层中却找不到它们明显的祖先。在《Darwin's Doubt》一书中，Stephen C. Meyer讲述了围绕这场动物生命大爆发的神秘谜团——这一谜团不仅因未曾发现这些动物预期的祖先而加深，更因科学家对构建一个动物实体所需条件的认知愈发深入而愈发难解……
Hacker News 上怎么说
正在加载完整评论……
……而且我们从来没见过无生命的东西变成生命。这个理论基本上是出于政治原因而非科学原因被学术界封杀了，但迈克尔·贝希（Michael Behe）和斯蒂芬·迈耶（Stephen Meyer）的书，尤其是《达尔文的疑惑》（Darwin’s Doubt）和《细胞中的签名》（Signature of the Cell），把论据讲得非常详尽。
…and we have never seen life come from non life. The theory has been essentially banished from academia for political, not scientific, reasons, but Michael Behe and Stephen Meyer’s books, specifically Darwin’s Doubt and Signature of the Cell, lay out the case in detail.
任何心态开放的人都应该读读斯蒂芬·迈耶（Stephen Meyer）写的《达尔文的疑惑》（Darwin's Doubt）。他探讨了寒武纪大爆发（Cambrian Explosion）的可能解释，并得出结论：智能设计论（Intelligent Design）是最好的解释。进化生物学家杰里·科因（Jerry Coyne）写过一篇反驳文章……
Anyone with an open mind should read Darwin's Doubt by Stephen Meyer. He looks at possible explanations for the Cambrian Explosion and concludes that Intelligent Design is the best explanation. Evolutionary Biologist Jerry Coyne has written a response…
C.S. 刘易斯的《纯粹基督教》（Mere Christianity）。十几岁时，它为我的信仰提供了理性基础，让我明白信仰是可以辩护的。还有斯蒂芬·迈耶的《达尔文的疑惑》（Darwin's Doubt）。如果上帝存在，方法论自然主义（methodological naturalism）就不可能完全正确。这本书让我意识到，科学依然有一些完全无法解释的领域，比如……的信息大爆发。
Mere Christianity by CS Lewis. As a teenager it gave me an intellectual basis for my faith and helped me see it could be defensible. Darwin's Doubt by Stephen Meyer. If God exists methodological naturalism can't be completely true. This book helped me see that there's still areas science can't fully explain, like the information explosion of the…
菲利普·约翰逊（Phillip Johnson）写的《审判达尔文》（Darwin on Trial）读来让人大开眼界、惊喜连连，我很推荐。你也可以读读迈耶的《细胞中的签名》（Signature in the Cell）和《达尔文的疑惑》（Darwin's Doubt）。其核心论点是“设计论证”（argument from design）——就像你看到一张纸被折成……的样子，你就能认出肯定存在一个纸飞机设计者一样。
"Darwin on Trial" by Phillip Johnson is an eye-opening and surprising read. I recommend it. You can also read "Signature in the Cell" and "Darwin's Doubt" by Meyer. The argument is the "argument from design" -- just like you would be able to recognize the existence of a paper-airplane-designer if you noticed a piece of paper folded into the shape of a…
额，你可以先读读这几本书：1. 菲利普·E·约翰逊的《审判达尔文》（Darwin on Trial） 2. 谭和施塔德勒的《通向生命的阶梯：生命起源的现实检验》（The Stairway To Life: An Origin-Of-Life Reality Check） 3. 斯蒂芬·C·迈耶的《达尔文的疑惑》（Darwin's Doubt）
Well, you could start by reading these books: 1. Darwin on Trial by Phillip E. Johnson 2. The Stairway To Life: An Origin-Of-Life Reality Check by Tan & Stadler 3. Darwin's Doubt by Stephen C. Meyer
……据我所知，在我看过的所有公开辩论中，迈耶就没输过，而且我从未读到过对他书中论点（《细胞中的签名》《达尔文的疑惑》以及《上帝假说的回归》）有力的反驳。我觉得迈耶远比站在另一边的各路学者和知识分子要可信得多、严肃得多……
…I am concerned, Meyer is undefeated in any public conversation that I have seen him engage in and I have never read a convincing rebuttal to the arguments he makes in his books (Signature in the Cell, Darwin's Doubt, and The Return of the God Hypothesis). I find Meyer to be a far more credible and far more serious intellectual force than the various academics and intellectuals that are associated with the other…