以慈善待所有人

With charity for all

Ken Stern · 初版 2013 年

2人推荐

2位读者提及

4次提及

作者曾是一家大型非营利机构的负责人，他在揭露慈善界令人震惊的种种乱象的同时，勾勒出了美国慈善事业的新范式；基于对缺乏问责机制的美国慈善机构的实地考察，他深刻洞察了非营利组织独特的市场激励机制与弊端。庞大且极少受到审视的美国慈善界，在全美经济活动中的占比足足达到10%，然而其运作却几乎缺乏问责制，毫无实际的准入门槛，更令人触目惊心地缺乏成效证据。本书揭开了一个潜藏于大庭广众之下的问题

Hacker News 上怎么说

jseliger · 2013 年
那根本不是真的。做慈善可不仅仅是给穷人扔钱而已。这是个很重要却没得到足够重视的观点。Ken Stern 在他的书《With Charity For All》里就阐述了这点，我在这篇博客里写得更详细：http://blog.seliger.com/2013/06/02/with-charity-for-all-ken-... 。本质上，我们在各种慈善事业上花了大把的钱，却根本不知道这些投入到底……
That is simply not true. Charity is not just about throwing money at poor This is an important and underappreciated point. Ken Stern makes it in his book With Charity For All, which I wrote more about here: http://blog.seliger.com/2013/06/02/with-charity-for-all-ken-... . In essence, we spend a lot of money on various charitable efforts without knowing what those efforts are…
jseliger · 2013 年
……因为他们的预算与具体服务绑定得太死了，以至于根本没办法搞清楚该如何规模化或者提高运作效率。想要了解更多，可以参考 Ken Stern 的书《With Charity For All》中的论证和大量案例。我在这里写过相关内容：http://blog.seliger.com/2013/06/02/with-charity-for-all-ken-... ，任何对非营利组织中慈善那一块具体是怎么运作感兴趣的人，都应该读读这本书。（我……
…since they can't figure out how to scale or operate more efficiently because their budget is tied so directly to services. For more than this, see the reasoning and extensive examples in Ken Stern's book With Charity For All. I wrote about it here: http://blog.seliger.com/2013/06/02/with-charity-for-all-ken-... , and anyone interested in how the charitable subset of nonprofits actually operate should read the book. (I'm…
wordcode · 2015 年
……保持了顶尖的专业技能。答案是——你的长期收入绝对会减少，尽管原因并不是上面提到的那些。进入非营利领域前必读的书：* Ken Stern 的《With Charity For All》 * Bill MacAskill 的《Doing Good Better》。另外，建议读读 SSIR，它对非营利领域新趋势的报道最全面：http://ssir.org/ 简短的回答是——如果收入很重要……
…maintained top skills. The answer is- your long term earnings will absolutely be reduced, though not for the already cited reasons. Essential books to read before going into the non-profit space: * With Charity For All - Ken Stern * Doing Good Better - Bill MacAskill Also, read SSIR, it has the best coverage of emerging trends in the non-profit space: http://ssir.org/ The short answer is- if income is important…
jseliger · 2013 年
没错。我意识到自己最近在 HN 上经常安利这本书，但 Ken Stern 的《With Charity For All》确实既讨论了 Givewell 的前景，也指出了其中的挑战——具体来说，很少有非营利组织真正去衡量、或者愿意去衡量产出的有效性。我是一名主要从事……的筹款申请书（grant writing）顾问
Correct. I realize that I've been talking about this book a lot on HN lately, but Ken Stern's With Charity For All discusses both the promise of Givewell and the challenges—specifically, few nonprofits actually measure, or want to measure, the efficaciousness of outcomes. I'm a grant writing consultant who works primarily…

正在加载完整评论……