凯恩斯、哈耶克
Keynes Hayek
Nicholas Wapshott · 初版 2011 年
1人推荐
4位读者提及
4次提及
随着 1929 年股市崩盘使全球陷入动荡，两位学者就如何让失衡的经济恢复平衡提出了针锋相对的主张。剑桥大学才思敏捷的经济学家 John Maynard Keynes 认为，在他人不愿消费支出时，政府有责任增加支出。与他立场相反的是当时鲜为人知的奥地利经济学教授 Friedrich Hayek，后者认为干预尝试既毫无用处又潜藏危险。战线由此拉开，Keynesian economics 随后主导了数十年，并造就了一个前所未有的繁荣时代，但保守派经济学家……
Hacker News 上怎么说
正在加载完整评论……
……在撒切尔和里根之前根本没人搭理货币主义，保罗·沃尔克当然也没当回事。尼古拉斯·瓦普肖特的《Samuelson Friedman》里有好几个章节讲到了这个：* https://wwnorton.com/books/9780393285185 （他的另一本书《Keynes Hayek》也写得很棒。）
…Thatcher and Reagan did anyone bother with monetarism, certainly Paul Volcker didn't. A few chapters on this in Samuelson Friedman by Nicholas Wapshott: * https://wwnorton.com/books/9780393285185 (His book Keynes Hayek is also good.)
我读完了尼古拉斯·瓦普肖特的《凯恩斯大战哈耶克：定义现代经济学的决斗》，2015年就开始读了。我还读了：* 《让船调头！：将追随者转变为领导者的真实故事》（大卫·马凯特）* 《工作的快乐：一场革命性的……
I finished Keynes, Hayek: The Clash that Defined Modern Economics (Nicholas Wapshott), started in 2015. I read: * Turn the Ship Around!: A True Story of Turning Followers into Leaders (David Marquet) * Joy at Work: A Revolutionary…
……在制定经济政策时，这种非理性的恐惧简直是在彻底污染讨论。[1]：经济学里很难找到科学证据，但这个特定话题正是大萧条时期“凯恩斯/哈耶克大论战”的核心争论点，而在这一点上，凯恩斯被证明是对的。
…irrational fear is really polluting the debate when it comes to defining the economic policies. [1]: scientific evidences are hard to find in Economics, but this particular topic was the point of the Keynes / Hayek controversy during the great depression and, on this particular topic, Keynes proved right.
……J. 布拉德福德·德龙写的二十世纪经济史。想看更多关于经济思想的内容可以看马克·卡尼（曾掌舵加拿大央行和英格兰银行）的《Value(s): building a better world for all》。还有瓦普肖特的《Keynes Hayek: the clash that defined modern economics》以及《Samuelson Friedman: the battle over the free market》。斯特凡·艾希的《The currency of politics: the political theory of money from Aristotle to Keynes》，《Money:…
…economic history of the twentieth century by J. Bradford Delong. More economic ideas stuff in Value(s): building a better world for all by Mark Carney (ran the Banks of Canada and England). Also Waphsott's Keynes Hayek: the clash that defined modern economics and Samuelson Friedman: the battle over the free market. The currency of politics: the political theory of money from Aristotle to Keynes by Sefan Eich, Money:…