当上帝开口说话
When God talks back
T. M. Luhrmann · 初版 2012 年
1人推荐
2位读者提及
2次提及
心理人类学家Luhrmann提供了一个深入的案例研究，探讨在当代美国世俗化压力之下，信徒如何建立起对一位活跃、临在的上帝的信仰。基于在葡萄园运动（Vineyard Movement）成员中开展的广泛访谈与个人经历，Luhrmann重点考察了灵恩派福音派基督徒对祈祷的运用。她的著作将个人叙事、畅销福音派实践指南摘录与心理学理论及实证数据融为一体。
Hacker News 上怎么说
正在加载完整评论……
…来自一种宗教背景，在那里上帝对你“说话”这种观念相当普遍。如果你想了解在当今现代社会中这怎么可能存在，我推荐谭雅·卢尔曼（Tanya Luhrmann）的《当上帝回话时》（When God Talks Back）。我觉得比起实际可能发生的情况，杰恩斯（Jaynes）把这种转变说得太突兀了。个体完全有可能频繁且反复地发展出他所说的那种“意识”，但未能……
…come from a religious background where the idea that God "talks" to you is quite prevalent. If you want an analysis of how could possibly be the case in our modern society, I recommend Tanya Luhrmann's "When God Talks Back". I say Jaynes puts the transition as far too sudden compared to what it actually could have been. Individuals could have had developed his version of "consciousness" often and repeatedly, but failed…
…对此可别言之过早。基督教中——特别是美国福音派基督教——有积极应对这类声音的方式：http://www.npr.org/2012/03/26/149394987/when-god-talks-back-... http://www.nytimes.com/2012/04/29/books/review/when-god-talk... 这些福音派教徒似乎就像是美国版的马赛人（Masai），能与死者对话。
…wouldn't be too certain about that. There are Christian- specifically American Evangelical Christian- approaches to responding to such voices in a positive way: http://www.npr.org/2012/03/26/149394987/when-god-talks-back-... http://www.nytimes.com/2012/04/29/books/review/when-god-talk... These Evangelicals seem to be the American equivalent to the Masai who speak to the dead.