迦太基必须毁灭
Carthage must be destroyed
Richard Miles · 初版 2011 年
3人推荐
4位读者提及
5次提及
迦太基人与罗马人之间的殊死搏斗是古代世界最具决定性的重大历史戏剧之一。在史诗般的陆战与海战中，双方都曾与胜利近在咫尺，最终迦太基人败下阵来，其都城、历史与文化几乎被彻底抹去。借助丰富的新考古研究成果，Richard Miles 生动地再现了这一失落的帝国——从其在黎巴嫩腓尼基人定居点的起源，到其登顶地中海最强大海上霸权的鼎盛时期。而在迦太基历史的核心深处……
Hacker News 上怎么说
正在加载完整评论……
不妨看看理查德·迈尔斯（Richard Miles）写的《迦太基必须毁灭：一个古老文明的兴衰》（Carthage Must Be Destroyed: The Rise and Fall of an Ancient Civilization）。迦太基在西班牙长期存在是毫无争议的。如果你要争辩说这对当地文化毫无影响，那你就得……
Try "Carthage Must Be Destroyed: The Rise and Fall of an Ancient Civilization" by Richard Miles. It is not in dispute that Carthage had a long presence in Spain. If you are arguing that this had no impact on local culture, you'd need…
……挺让我吃惊的。历史学家对迦太基的研究由来已久，关于布匿战争也有不少书，探讨了战争前夕及战争期间迦太基的状况（特别推荐理查德·迈尔斯的《迦太基必须毁灭：一个古老文明的兴衰》）。按理说 LLM 完全可以基于现有的这些文献来进行回答。
…surprising to me. Historians have long studied Carthage, and there are books you can get on the Punic Wars that talk about the state of Carthage leading up to and during the wars (shout out to Richard Miles's "Carthage Must Be Destroyed: The Rise and Fall of an Ancient Civilization"). I would expect an LLM to piggyback off of that existing literature.
这个月我读了《迦太基必须毁灭》（https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/10133950-carthage-must-b...），书里深入探讨了汉尼拔对罗马的战争（以及其他几场布匿战争）。我强烈推荐大家去读读，看看从……角度所发生的历史。
This month I read "Carthage Must Be Destroyed" (https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/10133950-carthage-must-b...), which dives deep into Hannibal's war against Rome (and the other punic wars). I highly recommend reading about what happened from the…
我目前正在读《迦太基必须毁灭》。如果你想从不仅仅是罗马人的视角来看待这段历史，我很推荐这本书。
I’m currently reading “Carthage must be destroyed”. If you want to look at the event from a not-solely Roman perspective I recommend this
……回报，最后还抱怨黄金已经被加工（成了雕像）。我猜那些雕像里有很多都被熔掉了。在 https://www.amazon.com/dp/0670022667/（《迦太基必须毁灭：一个古老文明的兴衰》）里有一些讨论，讲到青铜时代的腓尼基城邦（向埃及供应雪松木的来源）是如何在几个世纪里逐渐屈服于亚述帝国的扩张的。这……
…return, and concluded by complaining that the gold had been worked (into statues). I assume many of those statues got melted down. There is some discussion in https://www.amazon.com/dp/0670022667/ (Carthage Must Be Destroyed: The Rise and Fall of an Ancient Civilization) of how the Phoenician city-states of the bronze age (source of cedar wood to Egypt) gradually succumbed over the centuries to Assyrian empire-building. It's…