黄金国中的黑暗
Darkness in El Dorado
Patrick Tierney · 初版 2000 年
2位读者提及
2次提及
探讨了记者、人类学家和科学家对亚马逊流域最古老的部落之一——Yanomami印第安人所造成的破坏性影响。
Hacker News 上怎么说
正在加载完整评论……
Darkness in El Dorado
Patrick Tierney · 初版 2000 年
探讨了记者、人类学家和科学家对亚马逊流域最古老的部落之一——Yanomami印第安人所造成的破坏性影响。
正在加载完整评论……
……出现在了 José Padilha 那部关于人类学家的精彩纪录片《Secrets of the Tribe》里，算是一部揭露人类学肮脏内幕的片子，讲的是《Darkness in El Dorado》一书中那些争议指控引发的丑闻。我以前读过关于夏农（Chagnon）和亚诺马米人（Yanomami）的事，但从不知道现实竟然如此龌龊混乱。
…appears in José Padilha's fascinating documentary about anthropologists Secrets of the Tribe, kind of an exposé of dirty secrets of anthropology, and a scandal about controversial allegations in the book Darkness in El Dorado. I'd read about Chagnon and the Yanomami, but not the grubby shambolic reality.
……在被研究的原始社会中普遍存在的争夺统治权、地位竞争、肢体和性暴力，以及总体的冲突。关于 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Darkness_in_El_Dorado 的整起事件就是最著名的例子。虽然那些指控大部分都被证实不可信，但造成的伤害已经无法挽回。后果之一就是那些不顺从的人类学家被禁止进入委内瑞拉，而在那里有……
…competition for dominance, competition for status, physical and sexual violence, and overall strife present in primitive societies that were studied. The whole affair about https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Darkness_in_El_Dorado is the most famous example of this. The accusations were largely discredited, but the damage was done. One consequence is that unsympathetic anthropologists were banned from Venezuela, where there is…