血腥之地
Bloodlands
Timothy Snyder · 初版 2010 年
27人推荐
39位读者提及
48次提及
为什么值得读
- 严谨学术视角，提供平衡而有层次的二战历史入门
- 揭示德苏双重夹击下东欧犹太人与斯拉夫人的惨剧
- 重构对东欧战场极端残酷性及二战全局的认知
美国人将第二次世界大战称为“The Good War”。但在二战爆发前，美国的战时盟友 Josef Stalin 就已经杀害了数百万本国公民——并在战时及战后继续展开杀戮。在 Hitler 最终被打败前，他屠杀了六百万犹太人和几乎同等数量的其他欧洲人。战争结束时，德国与苏联的杀戮地点均落入了铁幕之后，使得大规模杀戮的历史陷入黑暗之中。Bloodlands 是一部开创性的欧洲历史著作，将纳粹与斯大林主义政权犯下的大规模屠杀展现为同一段历史的两个方面，
Hacker News 上怎么说
正在加载完整评论……
……我们那代人成长时读过的那位，是个时代的产物。现代学者多半只把他的书当作一手史料。沃尔夫冈·本茨的《第三帝国简史》、蒂莫西·斯奈德的《血色大地》、斯维特兰娜·阿列克谢耶维奇的《战争中没有女性的面孔》，以及伊迪丝·谢弗的《烧毁的桥梁》，对于想要这种更细致、更客观视角的读者来说，都是扎实的学术入门读物……
…of us were growing up, is a journalist who was the product of his time. His books are mostly regarded as a primary source by modern scholars. "Concise History of the Third Reich" by Wolfgang Benz, "Bloodlands" by Timothy Snyder, "The Unwomanly Face of War" by Svetlana Alexeivich, and "Burned Bridge" by Edith Sheffer are solid scholarly entry points for those of us for whom this more nuanced and even approach…
……这片领土最终落入了苏联手中）。有一本好书讲的就是希特勒帝国和苏联帝国如何夹击东欧的犹太人和斯拉夫人，导致数百万人丧生，书名叫《血色大地》（Bloodlands）https://www.amazon.com/Bloodlands-Europe-Between-Hitler-Stal...
…territory that eventually was held by the Soviets). There's a good book on how the empires of Hitler and the USSR squeezed between them the jews and slavs of Eastern Europe, resulting in millions of deaths, "Bloodlands" https://www.amazon.com/Bloodlands-Europe-Between-Hitler-Stal...
如果想看更现代一点的（而且参考了索尔仁尼琴本人的），我推荐蒂莫西·斯奈德写的《血色大地》。
For something more modern (and referencing Solzhenitsyn himself) I recommend _Bloodlands_ by Timothy Snyder.
……击沉了609艘船只，自身仅损失22艘U型潜艇。（https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Second_Happy_Time）最近有一本改变了人们对二战侧重点和认知的书，就是蒂莫西·斯奈德的《血色大地》，讲的是东欧战场上独一无二的野蛮残暴。
…sunk 609 ships at a loss of only 22 u-boats. (https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Second_Happy_Time) A recent examples of a book that has changed emphases and perceptions about WWII is Timothy Snyder's Bloodlands, on the unique savagery of the Eastern European conflict.
……他的脚肿了一星期。）他们占领的土地面积甚至更大。战后他们还干了些令人发指的事，比如为了自己的目的继续运作布痕瓦尔德集中营。想搞清楚这些，推荐去读读蒂莫西·斯奈德写的《血色大地》。依我看，这两帮人都该被拉清单。
…his feet for a week.) They even took up more square miles. And after the war, they did horrible things like keep Buchenwald running for their own purposes. A good place to understand this is to read _Bloodlands_ by Timothy Snyder. Send a bill to both of them I say.
……纳粹德国的镜像翻版（邪恶程度半斤八两——斯大林实际上在希特勒对犹太人下手之前，就已经对乌克兰人搞过种族灭绝了），请务必读读这本书：http://www.amazon.com/Bloodlands-Europe-Between-Hitler-Stali...
…mirror image of Nazi Germany (they were evil to same degree - Stalin actually pulled genocide on Ukrainians before Hitler did it to the Jews), please make sure to read this book: http://www.amazon.com/Bloodlands-Europe-Between-Hitler-Stali...