谁写了莎士比亚
Contested Will
James S. Shapiro · 初版 2010 年
2人推荐
2位读者提及
3次提及
Shakespeare 研究学者 James Shapiro 阐释了从何时起、因何缘故有如此多的人开始质疑 Shakespeare 是否亲自撰写了他的剧作。
Hacker News 上怎么说
正在加载完整评论……
Contested Will
James S. Shapiro · 初版 2010 年
Shakespeare 研究学者 James Shapiro 阐释了从何时起、因何缘故有如此多的人开始质疑 Shakespeare 是否亲自撰写了他的剧作。
正在加载完整评论……
目前在读：查理·斯特罗斯（Charlie Stross）的《暂停状态》（Halting State）；雅克·巴尔赞（Jacques Barzun）的《法语诗歌随笔：致英语诗读者》（An Essay On French Verse: For Readers of English Poetry）。刚读完：詹姆斯·夏皮罗（James Shapiro）的《争议意志：谁写了莎士比亚？》（Contested Will: Who Wrote Shakespeare?，非虚构类，强烈推荐；它更多是在梳理莎士比亚著作权争议的历史，而不是亲自加入这场论战）；伊恩·班克斯（Ian Banks）的《腓尼基启示录》（Consider Phlebas，文明系列（Culture series）的第一部，…
Reading right now: Charlie Stross, Halting State. Jacques Barzun, An Essay On French Verse: For Readers of English Poetry. Recently finished: James Shapiro, Contested Will: Who Wrote Shakespeare? (nonfiction, highly recommended; more about the history of the Shakespeare authorship controversy than a salvo in it) Ian Banks, Consider Phlebas (first book in the Culture series,…
……比莎士比亚早了四分之一个世纪，而且我们手头几乎没有任何他生前的文献证据，但也没人建个网站去证明《帖木儿大帝》（Tamburlaine）其实是本·琼森写的啊。詹姆斯·夏皮罗写的《争议意志》（Contested Will）是一部非常有趣的历史回顾，探讨了为什么在缺乏新证据的情况下，莎士比亚著作权争论依然如此阴魂不散、反复出现。他还讲到了这些说法最初是如何……
…quarter-century before Shakespeare and we have virtually no documentary evidence from his lifetime, and yet nobody is making websites to prove that _Tamburlaine_ was really written by Ben Jonson. The book Contested Will by James Shapiro is a really interesting historical review of why Shakespeare authorship theories are such a persistent and recurring thing, despite the lack of new evidence. He also covers how they got…
……更符合这个画像。培根、德比、牛津以及几十位其他声称者都被套用过完全一模一样的套路；几十年来，根本没人提出过任何真正针对莎士比亚的新论据。我推荐詹姆斯·S·夏皮罗（James S. Shapiro）的《争议意志：谁写了莎士比亚？》（Contested Will: Who Wrote Shakespeare?），这是一部考察、解释并驳斥各种著作权替代学说的权威之作。它深思熟虑、文笔极佳，绝不是那种枯燥的说教咒骂，可能……
…profile better. This exact process has been used for Bacon, Derby, Oxford, and dozens of other claimants; nobody has offered a truly new argument against Shakespeare for decades. I recommend the book _Contested Will: Who Wrote Shakespeare?_ by James S. Shapiro as the definitive work examining, explaining, and debunking alternative authorship theories. It's thoughtful and well-written, not the dry diatribe one might…