沙丘沙虫
Sandworms of Dune
Kevin J. Anderson、Brian Herbert · 初版 1994 年
2人推荐
5位读者提及
6次提及
Hunters of Dune 与大结局 Sandworms of Dune 汇聚了 Frank Herbert 经典 Dune 宇宙中的宏大故事线与备受喜爱的角色，涵盖了从 Butlerian Jihad 时期到原版 Dune 系列及其后期的广阔历程。这两卷作品直接依据 Frank Herbert 藏于保险箱内长达十年之久的最终大纲写成，终于解答了 Dune 粉丝争论了二十年之久的紧迫问题。在 Frank Herbert 的最后一部小说 Chapterhouse: Dune 的结尾，一艘载着难民的飞船逃入了未知的星系，逃离……
Hacker News 上怎么说
正在加载完整评论……
……在大多数讨论中我都算异类，因为我挺喜欢《异端》和《圣殿》里引入的银河系级威胁以及额外的世界观构筑元素，我甚至还在某种程度上挺喜欢布莱恩·赫伯特和凯文·J·安德森写的《沙丘猎鹰》与《沙丘沙虫》，觉得算是“尽力而为”的收尾之作。我确实觉得时间跳跃和原作者收尾的缺失稍稍拖累了《异端》和《圣殿》，而那些代笔写出来的……
…in most discussions in that I enjoyed Heretics and Chapterhouse for the galactic scale threat introduced and additional world building elements, and I even enjoyed (to some extent) Hunters of Dune and Sandworms of Dune by Brian Herbert and Kevin J. Anderson as a "best we could do" finale. I do think that the time skips and lack of original resolution hampered Heretics and Chapterhouse a little, and the ones written…
在读完了全部原著系列（从《沙丘》到《圣殿》）后，我后来又读了《巴特兰圣战》《沙丘猎鹰》和《沙丘沙虫》。综合来看，我觉得它们为原著系列提出的问题提供了充分的背景信息和交代。值得注意的是，虽然最后两本是布莱恩·赫伯特和凯文·安德森写的……
After reading entire original series (Dune through Chapterhouse), I eventually read Butlerian Jihad, Hunters of Dune, and Sandworms of Dune. Taken together I felt they provided sufficient context and closure for questions posed in the original series. And notably, although they are written by Brian Herbert and Kevin Anderson, the last two…
……这些书，你要是好奇可以读读看，但尽管挂着那个世界观的名头，它们并不算真正的沙丘小说。我本着乐观和希望读了大概七本，但一点都不喜欢。即便是表面上根据弗兰克·赫伯特《沙丘 7》笔记写成的《沙丘沙虫》，我也觉得不好看，虽然它算是最不烂的一本了。
…books, read them out of curiosity if you like, but they're not really Dune books despite being in that universe. I've read about seven of them out of optimism and hope but didn't enjoy them at all. Even Sandworms of Dune which is ostensibly based on Frank Herbert's notes for Dune 7 wasn't enjoyable to me, although it was least bad.
……在这里。如果你能啃完《神皇》，那就读《沙丘异端》。如果喜欢，再读《沙丘圣殿》。（如果不喜欢《异端》，就别费劲了）。为它的完结惋惜吧。如果非看不可，可以去读儿子写的《沙丘沙虫》，据说那是根据父亲的笔记写成的。这是我读过的儿子写的书里最不烂的一本了。其他的千万别碰。编辑：排版调整
…here. If you made it through God Emperor, read Heretics of Dune. If you enjoyed it, read Chapterhouse: Dune. (If you didn't enjoy Heretics, don't bother). Lament that it is over. If you must, read Sandworms of Dune which is written by the son, but is supposedly based on the father's notes. It is the least bad of the books I've read by the son. Don't read anything else. Edit: Formatting
《沙丘沙虫》太让人失望了，以至于我现在只去图书馆借这些书看。“前传”和“传奇”系列倒是写得足够好，我还特意去自费买了实体书。
Sandworms of Dune was such a disappointment that I'll check the books out of the library now. The "prelude" and "legends" series were good enough that I went out and bought my own copies of them.
……这正是我对待文艺作品观念不同的根源——我认为后出的作品不可能倒戈贬低前作的价值。比如，我在读《沙丘》时获得的乐趣，丝毫没有被《沙丘沙虫》冲淡。
…root of the difference in my take on media - I don't believe it's possible for a later instalment to retroactively devalue previous ones. e.g. The enjoyment I got from reading Dune wasn't diminished by Sandworms of Dune.