……把这种区分斥为咬文嚼字的语义之争。在我看来，这是一个极其耐人寻味的社会学和哲学现象。其他对这段文化历史感兴趣的人，我强烈推荐 William Patry 写的《Moral Panics and the Copyright Wars》。
…dismiss the distinction as semantic quibbling. To me, this is a fascinating sociological and philosophical phenomenon. For anyone else who is interested in this cultural history, I highly recommend "Moral Panics and the Copyright Wars" by William Patry.
……Ars 的那几篇文章详细讲了，好莱坞每次面对新技术——包括复印机和 VCR——都会大喊“世界末日来了！”。最棒的严肃学术法学著作出自一位叫 William Patry 的大佬之手。他的两本书《Moral Panics and the Copyright Wars》和《How to Fix Copyright》是这里最相关的，不过鉴于你大概只有 3 天时间，读起来篇幅相当长。你可能听说过也可能没听过他的名字，但他写过一套极其庞大的版权法系列著作……
…the articles at Ars went over how Hollywood has predicted "DOOM!" for every new tech, including the copier & VCR. The best serious scholarly legal works are by a guy named William Patry. His books _Moral Panics and the Copyright Wars_ and _How to Fix Copyright_ are the two most relevant here, though it's quite a long read given that you have like 3 days. You may or may not know that name, but he wrote a huge series on copyright law…
……毕竟反对 SOPA 的理由多得很，哲学层面的和现实层面的都有。不过回过头来深入探讨哲学层面，这里摘录了一篇评价 Patry 的《Moral Panics and the Copyright Wars》的优秀书评，其中谈到了部分相关问题：http://ip.jotwell.com/bill-patrys-war-on-copyright-rhetoric/ “Patry 的书重点探讨了修辞与隐喻在立法和公众辩论中所扮演的角色……
…are plenty of reasons to oppose SOPA, after all, both philosophical and practical. But to return to and expand upon the philosophical side of things, here is an excerpt from a good review of Patry's _Moral Panics and the Copyright Wars_ that deals with some of these issues: http://ip.jotwell.com/bill-patrys-war-on-copyright-rhetoric/ "Patry’s book focuses on the role rhetoric and metaphor have played in legislative and public debates…
……把这种区分斥为咬文嚼字的语义之争。在我看来，这是一个极其耐人寻味的社会学和哲学现象。其他对这段文化历史感兴趣的人，我强烈推荐 William Patry 写的《Moral Panics and the Copyright Wars》。
…dismiss the distinction as semantic quibbling. To me, this is a fascinating sociological and philosophical phenomenon. For anyone else who is interested in this cultural history, I highly recommend "Moral Panics and the Copyright Wars" by William Patry.
……Ars 的那几篇文章详细讲了，好莱坞每次面对新技术——包括复印机和 VCR——都会大喊“世界末日来了！”。最棒的严肃学术法学著作出自一位叫 William Patry 的大佬之手。他的两本书《Moral Panics and the Copyright Wars》和《How to Fix Copyright》是这里最相关的，不过鉴于你大概只有 3 天时间，读起来篇幅相当长。你可能听说过也可能没听过他的名字，但他写过一套极其庞大的版权法系列著作……
…the articles at Ars went over how Hollywood has predicted "DOOM!" for every new tech, including the copier & VCR. The best serious scholarly legal works are by a guy named William Patry. His books _Moral Panics and the Copyright Wars_ and _How to Fix Copyright_ are the two most relevant here, though it's quite a long read given that you have like 3 days. You may or may not know that name, but he wrote a huge series on copyright law…
……毕竟反对 SOPA 的理由多得很，哲学层面的和现实层面的都有。不过回过头来深入探讨哲学层面，这里摘录了一篇评价 Patry 的《Moral Panics and the Copyright Wars》的优秀书评，其中谈到了部分相关问题：http://ip.jotwell.com/bill-patrys-war-on-copyright-rhetoric/ “Patry 的书重点探讨了修辞与隐喻在立法和公众辩论中所扮演的角色……
…are plenty of reasons to oppose SOPA, after all, both philosophical and practical. But to return to and expand upon the philosophical side of things, here is an excerpt from a good review of Patry's _Moral Panics and the Copyright Wars_ that deals with some of these issues: http://ip.jotwell.com/bill-patrys-war-on-copyright-rhetoric/ "Patry’s book focuses on the role rhetoric and metaphor have played in legislative and public debates…