为什么我不是基督徒
Why I am not a Christian
Bertrand Russell · 初版 1927 年
6人推荐
13位读者提及
13次提及
为什么值得读
- 文字极其精练且易读性强
- 逻辑清晰有力带来耳目一新的观点
- 适合作反思宗教与学习哲学的入门材料
《Why I Am Not a Christian》是英国哲学家 Bertrand Russell 撰写的一篇文章。该文最初是 1927 年 3 月 6 日在国家世俗协会南伦敦分会赞助下，于巴特西市政厅发表的演讲，同年作为小册子出版，随后以英文和多种译本多次重印。
Hacker News 上怎么说
正在加载完整评论……
……向人们推荐哲学，而不是宗教。伯特兰·罗素（他也因数学方面的成就闻名）是个极佳的入门选择。编辑：对于持不同意见的人，我推荐罗素的一篇文章《我为什么不是基督徒》[0]。篇幅挺短，而且很好读。https://users.drew.edu/~jlenz/whynot.html
…recommend philosophy to people, instead of religion. Bertrand Russell (also known for his mathematical work) is an excellent place to start. EDIT: For those who disagree, I'd recommend a Russell's essay "Why I Am Not A Christian" [0]. It is quite short and readable. https://users.drew.edu/~jlenz/whynot.html
为了客观起见，你应该去读读摩门教创始人约瑟夫·史密斯的生平，以及他的诈骗历史。接着你还可以读读伯特兰·罗素的《我为什么不是基督徒》：https://users.drew.edu/~jlenz/whynot.html，篇幅很短。
In the interests of balance you should read up on the life of Joseph Smith, the founder of the Mormons, and his history of fraud. You could follow up with Why I Am Not a Christian by Bertrand Russell: https://users.drew.edu/~jlenz/whynot.html It's pretty short.
伯特兰·罗素的《我为什么不是基督徒》（1分），16年的天主教灌输洗脑（0分）。
Why I Am Not a Christian, by Bertrand Russell (1), 16 years of Catholic indoctrination (0).
……虽然带有论战色彩，但写得很棒。尼采的书只要你读完别——你懂的——变成该死的哥特风之类的人，或者跑去搞种族灭绝什么的，那就一直很值得一读。罗素的《我为什么不是基督徒》以及那本少有人读的文集《罗素论宗教》（据我所知学术界之外很难买到）——罗素文笔极佳，而且讲了些让人耳目一新的话，比如：<blockquote>哪怕……
…is polemical, but is well-written. Nietzsche is always good to read so long as you don't - you know - become a damn goth or whatever after reading it or try and commit genocide or something. Russell's "Why I Am Not A Christian" and the much less read compilation "Russell on Religion" (not widely available outside academia as far as I'm aware) - Russell is a good writer and says some very refreshing things like: <blockquote>Even…
……《柏拉图对话录》《天国的早期历史》《信仰的终结》《上帝的进化》《上帝的错觉》《上帝病毒：宗教如何感染我们的生活与文化》《道德景观》《谁写了圣经》《我为什么不是基督徒》。这些只是我读过的关于该主题的部分书籍，但还有其他评价很高、广受推荐的书我仍然想去读。不过，这几本真的很棒。如果这份书单看起来让人望而生畏……
…Dialogues of Plato The Early History of Heaven The End of Faith The Evolution of God The God Delusion The God Virus How Religion Infects Our Lives And Culture The Moral Landscape Who Wrote the Bible Why I am not a Christian These are just some of the books I have read on the subject, but there are others highly rated and recommended that I still want to go through. However, these are really good. If this list seems daunting…
……现代哲学家之一，主要是因为他的书太好读了，而且在他那个时代也算是个文化偶像。我对他的作品有种特殊的偏爱，因为当年我对自己的信仰产生怀疑时，《我为什么不是基督徒》帮我找到了言辞来表达我与天主教的决裂。他的《西方哲学史》被认为是哲学史的基石之作（尽管现在看来有点过时了）。他的著作……
…philosopher's of modern times, mostly because he's so easy to read and was somewhat of a cultural icon during his time. I have a particular fondness for his work because when I had doubts about my faith, "Why I Am not A Christian" helped me find words to communicate my break with Catholocism. His "History of Western Philosophy" is considered a cornerstone history of philosophy book (although it is somewhat dated now). His writings…